Interestingly enough...... Ive thought about this same question time and time again. Having owned Evora S then to Exige then back to Evora S I feel that I can talk with some authority on the subject!
My own personal view? (and one which I have heard muttered by others.....) - Exige is the faster track car - Evora S is the faster road car. A number of factors might lead me to believe this - power steering/ longer wheelbase for stability and softer suspension are the three areas where I believe the Evora is a more sorted road car (and therefore a more capable point to point steer). Once I have the Evora back to the approximate power/ weight of the Exige (really only achievable by piling on the BHP of the Evora as I have no desire to lose the rear seats or compromise on sound-proofing, etc), then I think the Evora will be unstoppable.
Have I explained this well enough? Im really not sure if I have. Tell you what....... how about this:
The Exige does everything that a thoroughbred sports cars should (in my opinion). It is extremely accomplished at covering ground in an astonishing quick way. It accelerates/ corners and stops like no other car that I have had the fortune to drive - and the knowledge that you are practically the quickest thing on the road leaves one feeling ever so slightly smug. For me it wasn't that the Exige did anything 'badly',.... rather..... some elements in its armoury were missing altogether. The Evora comes equipped with around 80% of the Exiges formidable arsenal - and then tops it off by being softer/ easier to drive/ more comfortable and much better equipped. Overall the Evora is just a brilliant piece of Lotus engineering - a possible "sleeper" - sometimes over shadowed by its more extreme siblings, but actually i think its the pick of the bunch. Undoubtably expensive for a Lotus - but cheap compared to something like a 911.
Im enjoying driving my Evora more now than I think I ever enjoyed driving the Exige. I used to get up early on a sunday morning before the roads got busy and take the Exige for a 10/10ths ride over the Pass of Ballater, over Gairn Shiel towards Strathdon and back to Aboyne via Logie Coldstone. It was immense, it was exhilarating - but after a while it got a little tiresome. Thats when I realised (for me), that this was really all the Exige could do. Unless you were balls to the wall I didn't think it came alive. I now regularly enjoy the Evora at 6, 7, 8/10ths - and so, for me, its a more fun car to drive more of the time
