Page 1 of 2

Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2011 10:53 am
by mrbennybennett
Anyone got any decent ideas?

Last year had the Lotus, Clio and girlfriends Mini Cab on the Admiral Multicar Policy - all in it was about £950ish

Renewal is in and is now £1,450 ish so have decided to stick the Lotus with CCI for the TD cover - quote is £150 cheaper than admiral !

not sure who to try for the clio and mini - done the usual Confused.com crap and that wasn't any cheaper also tried direct line - again not great

Do the likes of Richard Eggar cover "normal" cars??

Any other ideas much appreciated

Cheers

Benny

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2011 10:59 am
by Shug
Can't help too much, but I've noticed that while my Elise continues to drop insurance-wise, the S8 took a hike last year - even checking the compare sites and doing some phone haggling with current insurer. Ended up with Admiral again for the S8, CCI for the Lotus.

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2011 11:54 am
by Stu160
I have my cars with Swift cover, and Elephant, cheepest for us, 3 cars, £700 in total.

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2011 12:02 pm
by scottishselise
Swift have also been very good for me. Helps if a few years no claims as some friends got poorer quotes for 'perceived' higher risk.

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2011 1:49 pm
by Lazydonkey
Admiral HALVED my renewal when i queried it. :shock:

I did an individual quote on their site for the panda and primera, found them both to be cheaper than the multicar quote - then did a quote on multicar for my neighbour and then called armed with those stats.

£1800 to £900something.

Do your research, call them up and hit them with the "i'm so disappointed" line and you might be surprised :thumbsup

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2011 2:27 pm
by j2 lot
Lazydonkey wrote:Do your research, call them up and hit them with the "i'm so disappointed" line and you might be surprised :thumbsup
I tried that and 'next doors quote' was about £150 cheaper but still no where near as cheap as insuring 3 cars separately and they weren't interested in matching the multi quote to 3 separate quotes.
:roll:

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2011 3:04 pm
by Lazydonkey
j2 lot wrote:
Lazydonkey wrote:Do your research, call them up and hit them with the "i'm so disappointed" line and you might be surprised :thumbsup
I tried that and 'next doors quote' was about £150 cheaper but still no where near as cheap as insuring 3 cars separately and they weren't interested in matching the multi quote to 3 separate quotes.
:roll:
From memory my neighbour was £500 cheaper, but when i had the chat they were actually amazingly helpful......although to be clear i was comparing their multiple quotes with individual quotes from Admiral.

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2011 3:58 pm
by renmure
I am sure these things must go in cycles, but at the moment I have cover on a couple of cars with Aviva by going through their website.

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2011 4:30 pm
by mrbennybennett
Aviva is decent on my Clio saved about £100 :thumbsup but more expensive on the mini :roll:

Gettign there though !!

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2011 4:39 pm
by BiggestNizzy
I am with admiral and they are cheap (if nothing else) I will change next year however as they have an issue with Ann and my new car.

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 4:01 pm
by neil
I've just moved my non-Lotus to Swift Cover - paid about half of what my renewal quote had been from eCar. Just noticed I could have got cashback through Quidco too :roll:

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 7:12 pm
by mrbennybennett
Managed to get an online quote over £200 less than my renewal quote from Admiral - so called up they said they would match it then knocked off another £45 :)

Even though i had phoned them up on Friday proir to this saying i had better quotes from Aviva at about £750, but they said they were not willing to drop below their current quote of £960 :roll:

Why they have to fanny you about in the first place really pi55es me off

So Mini and Clio still with Admiral for £706 and the Elise with CCI for £408

Happy with that as the renewal quote was about £1,450

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2011 11:08 pm
by Andy G
Hi mate. Was about to say I saved £600 by quoting them my renewal vs their web price! The fcuk. What a waste of time!

Still adding the f430 was £400 :damnfunny :thumbsup

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 12:08 am
by Sanjøy
I think it was Admiral last year who wanted photos of the garage as they could not see it on google maps or street view... :shock:

Re: Decent Insurer for Non Lotus?

Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 12:18 pm
by Dominic
I have just had a client telling me about " top cash back .co .uk " as a great means of getting insurance (amongst other things) cheap. It came up in conversation as I asked how he managed to get full comp insurance on his fiat for £90!!! I have no idea how the website works, or if it's any good, but thought it would be worth investigating. :thumbsup